Op-Ed: Federalism under the Indian Constitution Metaphorized as the Tower of Babel or the Law of Viscosity

M.K.Sudarshan

November 16, 2026: Chennai, India


Is Indian federalism a Tower of Babel of competing dialects, or a non-Newtonian fluid governed by the Law of Viscosity?

My new Op-Ed on the dynamic friction between New Delhi and the States—and what Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer taught us about a living Constitution

Ask ten constitutional lawyers to define “federalism,” and you will receive at least three irreconcilable grammars.

In Washington, the word evokes a historic struggle to guard pre-existing state sovereignty against an encroaching central leviathan.

In Brussels, paradoxically, a “federalist” is one who seeks to pool stubborn national sovereignties into a deeper supranational union.

And in New Delhi, the term becomes an ongoing site of constitutional contestation—caught between those who read the 1950 text as a charter for unitary dominance and those who defend it as a covenant of inviolable regional autonomy.

In this sense, modern federalism resembles the biblical Tower of Babel. Humanity sets out to build a shared political edifice using a single word, only to discover that the builders speak mutually unintelligible dialects.

When a centralist in New Delhi invokes “national integrity” and a state-rights advocate invokes “the Basic Structure,” they are often translating the same constitutional text into two entirely different languages.

Yet in the myth, linguistic confusion halts the tower; in constitutional democracy, the refusal to collapse into a single monolingual voice is precisely what keeps the structure standing. A purely unitary state insists on speaking only one tongue—an ambition that works in compact, homogeneous polities, but breeds alienation or fragility across a vast, plural subcontinent.

Conversely, an unbridled confederation lets every unit speak only its own dialect until collective action dissolves into gridlock. Federalism is the institutionalized art of translation between the center and the periphery.

Still, if the Tower of Babel explains how we speak about federalism, it does not fully capture how the Indian Constitution behaves under political pressure.

Traditional political science offers static culinary metaphors—the “layer cake” of dual federalism or the “marble cake” of cooperative governance. Neither does justice to the dynamic tension built into India’s constitutional design. A truer analogy lies in fluid mechanics: the law of viscosity.

In physics, viscosity measures a fluid’s resistance to flow or gradual deformation under shear stress—the internal friction generated as adjacent layers slip past one another. Under the Indian Constitution, the Union and the States operate precisely as two adjacent layers of sovereignty compelled to slide past one another across overlapping fields of governance, from the Concurrent List to the GST Council.

Consider what happens at the extremes of viscosity.

In an inviscid fluid—where internal friction is zero—any sudden shear stress causes the layers to detach completely. That is the peril of a loose confederation, where centrifugal forces pull the union apart.

At the opposite extreme lies infinite viscosity: a rigid solid. A purely unitary constitution has no internal give; when subjected to intense regional, linguistic, or democratic stress, it cannot absorb the force through movement, and instead risks brittle fracture.

The genius—and the perpetual friction—of the Indian constitutional paradigm lies in its calibrated viscosity. The framers of 1950 deliberately rejected K.C. Wheare’s textbook ideal of a classical federation.

Haunted by Partition and the task of integrating over five hundred princely states, they engineered a “state-nation” with enough internal drag to prevent secession, yet enough fluidity to accommodate deep cultural and linguistic diversity.

Even more remarkably, Indian federalism behaves like a non-Newtonian fluid, whose thickness alters depending on the stress applied to it.

Under acute existential stress—external war, internal emergency under Article 352, or constitutional breakdown—the system exhibits shear-thickening, stiffening into a near-unitary monolith to preserve the Republic.

Yet under sustained peacetime democratic pressure—the linguistic reorganization of states, the rise of regional parties, or landmark Supreme Court interventions like S.R. Bommai and Mohit Minerals—the constitutional medium shear-thins, yielding space for states to flow along distinct policy trajectories.

Seen through this lens, constitutional offices are regulators of viscous drag.

When the Supreme Court enforces the Basic Structure doctrine, it prevents the fluid from solidifying into unitary authoritarianism. Conversely, when gubernatorial vetoes under Article 200 or centralizing fiscal architectures thicken the friction between New Delhi and state capitals, critics warn that the system is losing the very fluidity required to absorb democratic dissent.

Indeed, this is perhaps how one of India’s greatest constitutional jurists, Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer, might himself have chosen to characterize the Constitution of India.

A master of lyrical jurisprudence who famously viewed the Constitution not as a lifeless parchment of “wooden legalism” but as a vibrant, living organism pulsing with social dynamism, Krishna Iyer instinctively understood that constitutional power is kinetic rather than static.

In his celebrated opinion in State of Rajasthan v. Union of India (1977), he warned against reading Indian federalism through rigid, doctrinaire straitjackets—insisting instead on a “pragmatic, dynamic” federalism capable of adapting its rhythm to the lived realities of a diverse people.

To borrow his spirit, Babel and Viscosity would not be mere rhetorical flourishes, but apt descriptions of a living instrument designed to bend without breaking.

Perhaps, then, the debate dividing Indian constitutionalism need not choose between Babel and Viscosity; it needs both.

Babel reminds us that constitutional pluralism requires humility—an acceptance that “federalism” will always be spoken in multiple accents across our Republic.

Viscosity reminds us that friction between the Union and the States is not a constitutional defect to be eliminated, but the very physical property that holds the layers together while allowing the nation to move.

The enduring task of every generation of judges, lawmakers, and citizens is thus simply to ensure that the medium neither evaporates into fragmentation nor hardens into stone.

(Concluded)


Published by theunknownsrivaishnavan

Writer, philosopher, litterateur, history buff, lover of classical South Indian music, books, travel, a wondering mind

Leave a Reply