Mukkur Sri Lakshminarasimha Chariyar: On the Vedas- 6

A nearly forgotten chapter of modern Hindu religious history is being opened.

How does a Vedic life unfold in the twentieth century?

Not in isolation from the world—but in the midst of it.

Sri Mukkur Swami lived during a period of rapid social change, technological expansion, and cultural transition. Yet he remained firmly rooted in Vedic learning, Vaishnava devotion, ritual discipline, and the ideals of selfless service.

His life raises an enduring question:

Can ancient values still be practised—not merely admired—in modern times?

Mukkur Swami’s life offers a compelling answer.

*Vedam Parama Pramaanam* Part 6 -*

The Vedas are _‘Chatvaaro Vedah’._ We speak of them as Rig, Yajur, Sama, and Atharvana. Just as there are four Vedas, there are also four unshakeable, foundational attributes of the Veda. These are attributes unique to the Veda alone, impossible to find anywhere else. They call this _‘Anithara saadhaarana’_ (exclusive and unparalleled). You cannot find this elsewhere. These four unique attributes belong solely to the Veda, which is the Supreme Authority.

What are they..? The great Acharyas elaborate on this. Whether it is Sri Adi Shankara Bhagavatpada, the propounder of Vishishtadvaita Sri Ramanujacharya, or Sri Madhvacharya (Ananda Tirtha) – all three Acharyas unanimously declare this in one voice.

Look at how these philosophies (Matham) came to be. Advaita, Vishishtadvaita, Dvaita… _Matham_ means opinion or philosophy! This is Adi Shankara’s opinion . This is Ramanujar’s opinion . This is Ananda Tirtha’s opinion . They derived and presented their respective opinions based on their interpretation of the Veda. Those who followed their path, their disciples, have been adhering to those respective Sampradayas to this day..!

However, while there were differences in opinion among them when finding the meaning of the Veda, when interpreting it, *when it came to speaking about the Veda itself, when extolling the greatness of the Veda, everyone spoke exactly the same way..!* There was no difference of opinion among any of the Acharyas regarding that. Difference in opinion arose only when extracting the meaning of specific Vedic sentences. But when speaking about the nature of the Veda, our Vaidika Acharyas have all spoken in perfect unison..!

When we observe this, we see four unshakeable attributes belonging to the Veda: *_Nithyathvam (Eternality), Apaurusheyathvam (Non-human origin), Avicchinna Parambaraagathathvam (Unbroken lineage of transmission), and Ananthathvam (Infinity)._*

First is *Nithyathvam* – the attribute of Eternality. Nithyathvam means that which always exists. _‘Atha evacha Nithyathvam’_ says the Brahma Sutra. The Brahma Sutra declares, ‘Atha evacha Nithyathvam’ – therefore, the Veda is indeed eternal.
When discussing ‘Nithyam’ (Eternal), the Acharyas classified it into three categories: _Swaroopathah, Pravahathah, Swabhavathah._

Does the Veda have an eternal form?
Is it eternal through the continuous flow of time?
Does it exist perpetually? 
They inquired if the Veda truly exists in these ways.

Observe this carefully. We see the cycles of time passing—Krita Yuga, Treta Yuga, Dvapara Yuga, Kali Yuga. Countless Chatur Yugas continuously come and go. Even as the Yugas change, the Veda must remain unchanging in that continuous flow of time. Does it remain so..? Yes, it is existing..!

_‘Yo Brahmanam vidhadhaathi poorvam yo vai vedaamscha prahinothi thasmai’. _ It is said that Narayana created the four-faced Brahma from His lotus navel, and then… _‘Jagaadha Saamavedam tham Hayagreevam Upaasmahe’._ He bestowed the Vedas upon that Brahma. He initiated him into the Vedas. With his four faces, Brahma learned the four Vedas. From him, many others learned. Through an unbroken Guru-Shishya lineage (Oran vazhi), it has been grasped, retained, and taught by one person to the next, right up to this very day. Because of this, *it is eternal in the continuous flow of time.*

Next, observe how it exists eternally in its inherent nature. When speaking of this, the Acharyas said: _‘Yath satthve yath satthvam, yath abhaave thath abhaavah’._ This means: If the Veda exists, Paramatma exists. If there is no Veda, there is no Paramatma. Now, we will all agree with the first part. But not everyone will readily accept the second part. Everyone will agree that if the Veda exists, Paramatma exists. But how can one say that if there is no Veda, there is no Paramatma? Can we really say that if the Veda ceases to exist, Paramatma ceases to exist..?

Look at this world today. The number of people studying the Veda might decrease. Eventually, the chanting of the Veda on earth might even stop completely. Just because of that, can we say Paramatma doesn’t exist? Even if it is not chanted here on Bhooloka, it is being chanted elsewhere. It is being chanted in Devaloka, or in some other realm. If not in this town, it is chanted in another. Therefore, can we definitively say that without the Veda, Paramatma doesn’t exist..?

So, what is the true meaning of this statement? – Only if the Veda exists, can we truly realize that Paramatma exists..!! Because He can only be realized through the authority of the Veda (Pramaanam), and since realizing Paramatma without the Veda is extremely difficult, the Veda is paramount.

Therefore, it is said about Paramatma, _‘Yasya nisvasitham Vedah’ _ – the Veda is the very breath of Bhagavan. What gives a human being dignity and value? The presence of breath. As long as there is breath, there is value. If breath ceases, this physical body has no value. Similarly, if the Veda, which is His very breath, does not exist, Paramatma Himself loses His eminence.

That is why, if we want to state a truth, we state it by quoting the Veda. And if Bhagavan wants to instruct us, He says, _‘Veda moola pramanaath’_ – “Look at the Veda.” He Himself points to the Veda as the ultimate authority, stating that it is there in the text. Since the Veda connects us to Bhagavan and Bhagavan to us, *the Veda possesses the supreme attribute of being His very breath, existing eternally alongside Him.*

Furthermore, is it eternal in its form..?

_‘Namasthe the namo namasthe rudhra rudhra the namo namasthe rudhra the rudhra rudhra the the rudhra manyave manyave rudhra the the rudhra manyave’_
When this mantra is chanted, everyone immediately recognizes it as the Yajur Veda.

_‘The asmin vividhe vividhe’_ – Hearing this Swaram, we recognize it as the Rig Veda.

_‘Yadhaadhithyena vai sagasthaapayathi’_ – Hearing this, it is immediately identifiable as the Atharvana Veda.

_‘Hayaa hayaa haa oo haa oo haa’_ – This is unmistakably the Sama Veda.

Just by hearing the Swaram (intonation), we recognize it—this is Sama, this is Yajur, this is Rig, this is Atharvana. Because we are accustomed to hearing it, the distinct form of each Veda becomes clear to us. It exists precisely in that Swaram. *Thus, the Veda is eternally present in its structural form through its Swaram.* And as Bhagavan’s breath, it exists eternally with Him.

Apart from this, it has been transmitted through an unbroken lineage of instruction _(Upadesha Parampara)_ down to this very day. In all these ways—in its form, in its natural essence, and in the continuous flow of time—because the Veda exists eternally, the sound of the Veda remains indestructible. What do the Shastras say? During the time of Pralaya (cosmic dissolution), all sounds are destroyed. Whatever sounds exist in the world will be completely wiped out in the Maha Pralaya. But observe this: *Only the sound of the Veda is never destroyed.*

This supreme nature of the Veda is what all Acharyas have revealed.
Seeing Bhagavan,
_Aalaama maratthin ilaimel oru baalakanai_
_Gnalamezhu mundan Arangattharavinaiyaan_
_Kolaamamaani aaramum mutthutthaamamum mudivillathorezhil _
_Neelameni aiyyo niraikondathennenjinaiye_

Thus sang Thiruppaanazhwar. Looking at Ranganatha, he cried out _‘Aiyyo’..!_ ‘Aiyyo’—no further words came out. That is experience. They call it _‘Anubhava parivaaham’ (overflowing experience)._ Did he write that song to win a prize? No. He is looking at Him directly, and from that overwhelming experience, the words pour forth. When words failed him, he just said ‘Aiyyo’. He is saying, “The beauty of that divine dark form has completely captivated my heart, what can I do..!!”
What kind of Lord is He? He is the _Vatapatra Sayi,_ the one resting as a child on the banyan leaf.

_‘Baalam Mukundham manasaa smaraami_
_Karaaravindena padaravindam_
_Mukharavinde viniveshayantham_
_Vatasya patrasya puteshayaanam_
_Baalam Mukundham manasaa smaraami’_

_Munchaguncha thadhaathithi Mukundah:_ ‘Mu’ means Moksha (liberation). ‘Ku’ means the Aishwarya (wealth/prosperity) we need in this world. He is the one who bestows both. That child, Mukunda, the Vatapatra Sayi, rests on that banyan leaf.
Such a supreme Lord protects the Veda within Himself even during Pralaya. Then, during the cycle of creation, He initiates Brahma into the Veda again. From this, we must understand one thing – Are we protecting the Veda, or is Bhagavan protecting it..? Bhagavan protects it far more carefully than we do! He keeps it imperishable within Himself during Pralaya. He holds it within and then releases it again. Therefore, Paramatma is its ultimate protector.

The Veda is not destroyed even during the time of Pralaya. Therefore, we must realize that the Veda possesses the attribute of *_Nithyathvam_* —the quality of being eternal.

There are many other authorities (_Pramaanas_), many other literatures, and countless other sounds in the world. But they are all perishable. *We must realize that the Veda alone is imperishable.*

(Reproduced in English translation by Mukkur Sri Srinivasachariar (MLS Swami, ‘Tiru Kumarar’ of Mukkur Sri Lakshminarasimhachariar).

Sudarshan Madabushi

The Danger of Making Gen Z India’s New Moral Aristocracy

M.K.Sudarshan

November 18, 2026: Chennai, India

Democracy needs young voices. It does not need a new aristocracy of outrage.

Youthful idealism deserves a hearing—but not political worship, moral exemption, or the power to dictate to democratic institutions.

India’s political class has discovered a new object of devotion: Gen Z. Ministers, Opposition leaders, celebrities, editors and television anchors now compete to praise the “energy,” “idealism” and “digital courage” of the young. Some of this is welcome. Much of it is flattery. And a portion of it risks becoming something more troubling: the conversion of legitimate youth grievances into a politics of street pressure, moral blackmail and institutional intimidation.

The question is not whether young Indians have the right to protest. They do. The question is whether political parties, media commentators and protest entrepreneurs are helping young citizens use that right responsibly—or teaching them that democratic institutions may be bullied into submission by the loudest crowd.

A real grievance, not a manufactured one

The present unrest did not arise from nothing. The immediate trigger was anger over examination failures, including the alleged leak of the NEET-UG question paper, and demands for accountability from those responsible for a system on which millions of young Indians stake their futures. The protests were largely peaceful, and their early demands centred on examination reform, transparency and ministerial accountability.[1]

These are not frivolous demands. A young person who prepares for years, faces fierce competition, and then finds the examination system compromised has every reason to be angry. Nor is it illegitimate to ask whether public institutions are responsive, credible and fair.

But a genuine grievance does not automatically validate every demand made in its name. Nor does it justify converting a policy failure into a claim that an entire generation has been uniquely oppressed, disenfranchised, or entitled to a new category of “fundamental rights.”

From accountability to ultimatum

The Cockroach Janta Party began with a focused demand: accountability for examination failures and the resignation of the then education minister. That demand was met. But the movement then widened into demands for the resignation of the Chief Election Commissioner, criminal proceedings against him, a halt to electoral-revision processes, and broader changes to the electoral framework.

Here lies the problem. Citizens may certainly demand that a minister resign; ministers serve at the pleasure of political accountability. But the Chief Election Commissioner occupies a constitutionally protected office. Under Article 324 of the Constitution, the CEC can be removed only in the same manner, and on the same grounds, as a Supreme Court judge—through a parliamentary process involving specified majorities, an inquiry, and ultimately a presidential order.[2]

A 48-hour ultimatum followed by the threat of nationwide agitation may be effective politics. It is not constitutional politics. If allegations of misconduct are serious, they should be investigated and adjudicated through lawful channels. If they are not, no amount of street mobilisation should be allowed to decide the matter.

The difference between protest and coercion

Peaceful protest is not anarchy. Article 19 of the Constitution protects freedom of speech and the right to assemble peaceably and without arms. But those rights are subject to reasonable restrictions in the interests of public order, and any restriction must be lawful, necessary and proportionate.[3]

The distinction is straightforward:

  • Citizens may assemble, argue, petition, litigate, campaign and vote.
  • They may criticise ministers, judges, election commissioners and prime ministers.
  • They may not use violence, intimidate fellow citizens, damage property, obstruct ordinary life, or seek to force constitutional authorities to resign through mob pressure.
  • They may not treat every police restriction as fascism, nor every judicial refusal as betrayal.

A democracy needs protest. It also needs limits. When protest becomes a veto over institutions, it ceases to be democratic participation and becomes coercive politics.

The parties’ convenient embrace

The INDIA alliance has been quick to embrace the youth movement. Congress and allied parties have joined protests, mobilised cadres, endorsed demands for the CEC’s resignation, and presented the agitation as the voice of India’s youth, women, farmers and workers.

There is nothing inherently improper in parties responding to public anger. That is what opposition politics is for. But there is a difference between supporting a citizen’s right to peaceful protest and lending legitimacy to ultimatums, abusive rhetoric, or pressure on constitutional institutions.

When established parties applaud every escalation, they encourage a dangerous lesson: that moral indignation can substitute for evidence, and that street theatre can substitute for parliamentary argument. That is not empowerment. It is a recipe for a politics in which every grievance becomes a siege and every institution becomes a target.

The media’s role

The media has not been an innocent bystander. Some commentators have framed the protests in grand terms: youth liberation, resistance to authoritarianism, a democratic awakening. Such language may be emotionally satisfying, but it can obscure the harder questions: What exactly is being demanded? By whom? Through what constitutional means? And at what cost to citizens who are not part of the protest?

At the same time, it would be equally wrong to dismiss all youth dissent as orchestrated anarchy. The protests began with real concerns, and many participants were peaceful. A mature media should report both facts: the legitimacy of some grievances, and the danger of some methods.

The media’s duty is not to choose between flattering the young and defending power. It is to insist on evidence, proportion and constitutional limits.

What Rajaji and Sastri would ask

Srinivasa Sastri and C. Rajagopalachari were not enemies of freedom. They were men who understood, from the independence struggle, that agitation can be necessary when ordinary constitutional channels are closed. But they also understood that the habits of struggle can become dangerous in a free republic.

Rajaji himself acknowledged that the non-cooperation movement had left less desirable legacies, including habits of disregarding law and authority. His warning after Independence was that discipline could no longer rest on fear; it had to rest on voluntary acceptance of democratic norms.

Their likely question today would not be, “Why are young people angry?” It would be, “What are you asking for, and through what means?” A demand for examination reform is democratic. A demand that constitutional officers resign because a crowd has gathered is not.

A better politics for youth

India does not need Gen Z worship. It needs intergenerational seriousness.

Elders should listen to young people on employment, education, examinations, housing, mobility, digital life and public integrity. Young people should also recognise that governance is difficult, that institutions exist precisely to prevent power from becoming the property of the loudest group, and that democratic victories achieved through coercion are often short-lived.

Political parties should compete for youth votes through credible policies: better schools, credible examinations, job creation, administrative reform, transparent elections and accountable institutions. They should not compete to see who can praise youth outrage most loudly.

The real test

The real test of this moment is not whether Gen Z can mobilise. It plainly can. The test is whether India’s political class can channel that energy into constitutional politics rather than mob politics.

A government with a popular mandate must still be accountable. An Opposition has a duty to challenge power. Citizens have a right to protest. But none of these truths cancels the others.

India will remain a democracy not because its streets are always full, but because its institutions remain strong enough to hear dissent without surrendering to it—and because its citizens, young and old alike, are mature enough to demand justice without mistaking coercion for freedom.

The future of Indian democracy will not be decided by who can shout loudest, march furthest, or trend fastest. It will be decided by whether we can still distinguish the right to be heard from the power to dictate.

(Concluded)



Sources:
[1] Student Protests in Delhi and India 2026: Gen-Z’s Frustration and Fight for Reforms – PRIF BLOG https://blog.prif.org/2026/08/05/student-protests-in-delhi-and-india-2026-gen-zs-frustration-and-fight-for-reforms/
[2] CEC Impeachment Process Explained: How Can India Remove an … https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-law/cec-impeachment-process-removal-election-commissioner-explained-10944874/
[3] Delhi protest restrictions: Can police stop peaceful protests … https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/explained-law/delhi-protest-restrictions-supreme-court-rights-10917775/
[4] Meeting of CJP, Union ministers underway after Dharmendra Pradhan’s resignation – The Economic Times http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/meeting-of-cjp-union-ministers-underway-after-dharmendra-pradhans-resignation/printarticle/132624617.cms
[5] March fest in October: Opposition & ‘cockroaches’ to hit streets over EC row, Gyanesh Kumar’s resignation – The Economic Times http://www.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/protests-escalate-opposition-and-cockroach-janta-party-to-challenge-election-commission-over-gyanesh-kumars-resignation-sir/printarticle/134611750.cms
[6] Why India’s Cockroach movement wants the election chief … https://www.dw.com/en/india-cockroach-movement-targets-election-chief-over-voter-roll-dispute/a-79462036
[7] CJP, student groups unite against CEC Gyanesh Kumar, call for nationwide mobilisation https://www.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/cjp-student-groups-unite-against-cec-gyanesh-kumar-call-for-nationwide-mobilisation/articleshow/134761869.cms
[8] Can the Chief Election Commissioner be removed? What the law says https://www.theweek.in/news/india/2026/10/28/can-the-chief-election-commissioner-be-removed-what-the-law-says.html
[9] The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners … https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-chief-election-commissioner-and-other-election-commissioners-appointment-conditions-of-service-and-term-of-office-bill-2023
[10] Peaceful Protest And Public Order https://www.livelaw.in/articles/peaceful-protest-public-order-554688
[11] India’s opposition parties stage new protest against … https://apnews.com/article/india-opposition-protests-voters-elections-cockroach-party-cb532b4811eea64c51f61cd4199fb64e
[12] Angry youth | The rage of Gen Z https://www.indiatoday.in/amp/magazine/cover-story/story/20260803-angry-youth-the-rage-of-gen-z-cjp-protests-jantar-mantar-protests-2955213-2026-07-25
[13] CJP, or Cockroach Janta Party, calls for protests against … https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ck62mped4rz9o
[14] Rahul Gandhi: India’s opposition rallies against voter roll revision exercise https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c60qk92dvlwgo
[15] Ashok Swain on the Mounting Opposition to Modi’s Authoritarian Rule https://thediplomat.com/2026/11/ashok-swain-on-the-mounting-opposition-to-modis-authoritarian-rule/
[16] researchonline.lse.ac.uk › id › eprintIndia’s Gen Z are making accountability a condition of … https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/141112/1/inequalities_2026_8_26_india-gen-z-protests-citizenship-accountability.pdf
[17] Full text of “Speeches Of C. Rajagopalachari (jan1948-jan1950)” https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.206564/2015.206564.Speeches-Of_djvu.txt

Book Review of “Yajñeśa: The Life and Times of Mukkur Sri Lakshminarasimhachariar” by M. K. Sudarshan ( Blue Rose Publishers) in “Vainavan Kural” magazine (October 2026) by U.Ve. Sriman Valayapettai Ramacharyar

“Sthitaprajna”, “Ataraxia”, and “Ma’at”:

How Three Great World Civilizations, Searching in Parallel, Arrived at the Same Destination of the Ideal Human


M.K.Sudarshan

November 17, 2026: Chennai, India


Across the ancient world, separated by vast deserts, mountain barriers, and open seas, three great civilizations independently confronted the same enduring human dilemma: 

How does a human being remain inwardly steady, lucid, and whole while living in a world defined by impermanence, uncertainty, and suffering?

Along the fertile banks of the Nile, across the river plains and forest hermitages of India, and within the marble colonnades of Greece, thinkers arrived at remarkably similar answers. Though they spoke different languages, worshiped under different skies, and built radically different metaphysical systems, all three converged on a shared portrait of the ideal human being:

  • In Ancient Egypt, it was the Geru Maa—”the Truly Silent” or self-controlled sage—living in alignment with Ma’at (cosmic order, truth, and balance).
  • In Vedantic India, it was the sthitaprajna—”one of steady wisdom”—anchored in the unchanging Self (Atman) amidst the shifting tides of the material world.
  • In Ancient Greece, it was the sage of ataraxia—”un-troubledness”—possessing an unshakeable mental tranquility freed from irrational fear and craving.

For centuries, historians and philosophers debated whether this striking resemblance was the result of cultural borrowing—either from East to West or West to East. Yet when the historical, linguistic, and textual evidence is weighed carefully, a far more profound conclusion emerges: these three ideals were born independently through parallel philosophical discovery, only to recognize one another as kindred truths when trade, diplomacy, and empire eventually brought their worlds together.


I. The Nile and the Silent Sage of Ma’at

Our inquiry begins along the Nile, where one of humanity’s oldest continuous civilizations developed an intricate philosophy of inner and outer equilibrium nearly two millennia before classical Athens.

To the ancient Egyptians, the cosmos was not a random collision of forces; it was sustained by Ma’at—a foundational principle uniting cosmic law, seasonal rhythm, truth, justice, and personal integrity. Just as Ma’at kept the stars in their courses and brought the life-giving flood of the Nile each year, human beings were called to mirror that same steadiness within their own minds and communities.

Out of this worldview emerged the Egyptian ideal of the Geru Maa—literally, “The Truly Silent One” or “The Self-Controlled One.” In classical Egyptian Sebayt (“Wisdom Literature”), such as the Instruction of Ptahhotep (c. 2300 BCE) and the Instruction of Amenemope (c. 1100 BCE), the Geru Maa is vividly contrasted with the shemem—the “heated” or “hot-headed” person who reacts impulsively to insults, chases wealth feverishly, and collapses into despair when fortune turns.

“As for the heated man in the temple, he is like a tree growing indoors; only for a moment does it put forth shoots… The truly silent one sets himself apart; he is like a tree growing in a sunlit field—it flourishes, doubles its yield, and stands before its owner.”
— Instruction of Amenemope, Chapter 4

Crucially, Egyptian “silence” did not mean muteness, passivity, or withdrawal from civic responsibility. These wisdom texts were written primarily for judges, scribes, administrators, and citizens. To be a Geru Maa meant mastering anger, resisting greed, and speaking truth with measured calm so that one could uphold justice in society without becoming emotionally enslaved to public praise or sudden ruin.


II. The Ganga and the Sthitaprajna of Vedanta

Thousands of miles to the east, Indian sages were probing the same human predicament—pushing their inquiry into the deepest layers of consciousness itself.

Whether viewed through traditional Indian chronology—which places the events of the Mahabharata at the close of the Dvapara Yuga around 3102 BCE—or through modern philological scholarship, which traces the written compilation of the Bhagavad Gita to the final centuries BCE out of much older Vedic and Upanishadic oral streams, the Vedantic ideal of mental equipoise stands on unmistakably indigenous foundations.

In the second chapter of the Bhagavad Gita (verses 54–72), Arjuna asks Krishna how a person of steady wisdom—a sthitaprajna—speaks, sits, and walks in the world. Krishna’s reply remains one of world literature’s most penetrating portraits of psychological freedom:

“One whose mind is unshaken in adversity, who does not crave pleasure in prosperity, and who is free from attachment, fear, and anger—such a sage is called a sthitaprajna.”
— Bhagavad Gita 2.56

Like the Egyptian Geru Maa, the sthitaprajna is not an escapist hiding from reality. On the contrary, Krishna delivers this teaching on the brink of battle, urging Arjuna to engage fully in his duty (karma yoga) while surrendering obsessive attachment to the outcomes of his actions. Drawing a vivid natural metaphor, the Gita compares the wise person to a tortoise drawing its limbs safely into its shell—not out of fear, but out of sovereign self-mastery over the senses.

Underpinning this psychological poise is a distinct metaphysical insight: while the phenomenal world (Prakriti) is perpetually in motion like waves rising and falling on an ocean, the true Self (Atman) is the calm, immutable depth beneath. By discerning the difference between the fleeting outer world and the eternal inner witness, the sthitaprajna ceases to be tossed about by dualities—heat and cold, honor and disgrace, gain and loss.


III. The Aegean and the Quest for Ataraxia

On the rocky shores of Greece, a third great civilization arrived at a remarkably similar destination through its own native lineage of rational inquiry.

Long before Greek armies or merchants ever reached the Indus River, the pre-Socratic philosopher Democritus (c. 460–370 BCE) used the exact Greek term ataraxia—literally “un-troubledness”—alongside euthymia (“tranquility of soul”) to describe the supreme human good achieved by moderating desires and freeing the mind from fear. Building upon Socratic self-mastery (enkrateia) and Cynic self-sufficiency (autarkeia), the major Hellenistic schools placed ataraxia at the very center of human flourishing (eudaimonia):

  • Epicureanism sought ataraxia by understanding the natural laws of the universe (atomism) so that human beings would be liberated from superstitious dread of death and vengeful gods.
  • Stoicism sought ataraxia by aligning human reason with the rational order of nature (Logos), distinguishing strictly between what lies within our control (our judgments, intentions, and character) and what lies outside it (wealth, reputation, illness, and external events).
  • Pyrrhonism (Skepticism) sought ataraxia by suspending dogmatic judgment (epoché) on uncertain matters, discovering that peace of mind follows naturally when the intellect stops exhausting itself over rigid opinions.

“Men seek retreats for themselves—houses in the country, seashores, and mountains… Nowhere can a man find a quieter or more untroubled retreat than in his own mind.”
— Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 4.3

Just as in Egypt and India, Greek ataraxia was never intended to turn human beings into unfeeling stone. Stoics explicitly rejected emotional numbness; whether practiced by a freed slave like Epictetus or a Roman emperor like Marcus Aurelius, ataraxia provided an “inner citadel” that enabled citizens and leaders to serve humanity with clarity and courage.


IV. Borrowing or Parallel Discovery? Weighing the Historical Evidence

When scholars across the centuries noticed how closely sthitaprajna, ataraxia, and Ma’atresembled one another, two competing diffusion theories emerged:

  1. The “India-to-Greece” Claim of Antiquity: Many ancient Greek and Greco-Roman writers assumed that because Indian and Egyptian civilizations were far older than Athens, philosophy itself must have migrated westward. In the 2nd century CE, Clement of Alexandria wrote in his Stromata that philosophy flourished first among the Egyptians and the Indian Brahmins and Sramanas before reaching Greece, claiming that Pythagoras and Plato had learned their doctrines of the soul directly from Eastern sages. Writers such as Philostratus, Apuleius, and Lucian echoed similar traditions, while the Neoplatonist founder Plotinus even joined a Roman military expedition to Persia in 243 CE hoping to reach India and study under the Brahmins.
  2. The “Greece-to-India” Claim of the 19th Century: Centuries later, several European Orientalists—including Albrecht Weber, Christian Lassen, and W. W. Tarn—inverted the claim, arguing under the sway of colonial Hellenocentrism that Indian epics, drama, and philosophical systems must have borrowed heavily from post-Alexandrian Greece.

Modern comparative philosophy and historical scholarship—championed by thinkers such as Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, Surendranath Dasgupta, Bimal Krishna Matilal, Wilhelm Halbfass, and A. A. Long—have thoroughly dismantled both sweeping “copying” theories in favor of independent parallel development, while recognizing genuine points of historical contact:

  • Why Borrowing Is Ruled Out as the Primary Origin:
    • Chronology: Egyptian wisdom texts predated classical Greece by over a millennium; the early Upanishads predated Socrates and Zeno; and Democritus defined ataraxia in Greece a full century before Alexander the Great ever crossed the Hindu Kush (327 BCE).
    • Zero Textual Translation: Not a single Sanskrit philosophical work—neither the Upanishads nor the Bhagavad Gita—was translated into Greek in antiquity, nor was a single work of Plato, Aristotle, or Zeno translated into Sanskrit.
    • Distinct Metaphysical Roots: Borrowed concepts carry the DNA of their parent system. Yet sthitaprajna is inseparable from karma, rebirth (samsara), and union with Brahman; Greek ataraxia rests on atomistic materialism or Stoic Logos; and Egyptian Geru Maa rests on cosmic Ma’at and judgment before Osiris.
  • Where Genuine Cross-Pollination Did Occur:
    • Egypt to Greece: Unlike distant India, Egypt sat directly across the Mediterranean from Greece. From the 7th century BCE onward, Greek thinkers—including Thales, Pythagoras, Solon, and Plato—visited Egypt and openly acknowledged their debt to Egyptian priestly wisdom.
    • India and Greece After Alexander: When Alexander reached Taxila in 327 BCE, the Greek philosopher Pyrrho of Elis spent roughly eighteen months observing Indian ascetics (whom the Greeks called gymnosophists), such as Kalanos and Dandamis, who remained utterly unmoved by physical pain, royal threats, and death. Scholars widely recognize that Pyrrho’s firsthand encounter with Indian ascetic equanimity directly shaped his formulation of Skeptical ataraxia upon returning to Greece.
    • Mauryan Diplomacy and Indo-Greek Dialogue: Around 300 BCE, the Greek ambassador Megasthenes resided at Chandragupta Maurya’s court in Pataliputra. In his Indica, he marveled that the teachings of the Indian Brachmanes on the soul and cosmos coincided remarkably with Plato’s, while also recording widespread devotion to Vasudeva-Krishna (“Herakles”) among the Shurasenas of Mathura. Two centuries later, the Indo-Greek king Menander I debated the Buddhist sage Nagasena in the Milinda Panha, and the Greek envoy Heliodorus erected a pillar at Vidisha around 113 BCE declaring himself a devotee of Krishna and inscribing verses echoing the Mahabharata on self-restraint and alertness.
    • The Crossroads of Alexandria: Finally, in cosmopolitan Alexandria—where Nile barges met Mediterranean galleys and monsoon merchant ships returning from Indian ports—Egyptian, Greek, and Indian traditions converged in the same intellectual marketplace, allowing thinkers like Clement and Plotinus to trace the golden thread linking all three.

V. Understanding Reality, Not Escaping It

Viewed side by side, the civilizational quests of Egypt, India, and Greece correct a persistent modern misunderstanding about inner peace.

None of these three traditions sought to insulate human beings from life by building a padded wall against reality, nor did they aim to make the mind cold, apathetic, or inured to human suffering. On the contrary, all three insisted that deep comprehension of the phenomenal world is the very key to mental freedom:

  • Egypt studied the cosmic and social laws of Ma’at so the Geru Maa could act justly without anger.
  • India analyzed the shifting nature of Prakriti and the unchanging witness of Atmanso the sthitaprajna could perform sacred duty without anxiety.
  • Greece investigated the physical and rational laws of nature so the seeker of ataraxia could meet fate without fear.

In each civilization, the goal was not to flee the storm of existence, but to build a keel deep enough that the vessel would remain upright in any weather.


Conclusion: Three Lamps on the Same Summit

That three great civilizations—working independently across millennia and continents—arrived at nearly identical portraits of the ideal human being is one of the most illuminating facts of intellectual history. It suggests that sthitaprajna, ataraxia, and Ma’atare not merely local cultural artifacts; they are convergent discoveries about the architecture of the human mind itself.

Whenever human beings look honestly at the impermanence of fortune and the restlessness of desire, wisdom points toward the same quiet summit: to see the world clearly without illusion, to act within it responsibly without attachment, and to guard an inner stillness that no outward storm can ever take away.

(Concluded)


Op-Ed: Federalism under the Indian Constitution Metaphorized as the Tower of Babel or the Law of Viscosity

M.K.Sudarshan

November 16, 2026: Chennai, India


Is Indian federalism a Tower of Babel of competing dialects, or a non-Newtonian fluid governed by the Law of Viscosity?

My new Op-Ed on the dynamic friction between New Delhi and the States—and what Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer taught us about a living Constitution

Ask ten constitutional lawyers to define “federalism,” and you will receive at least three irreconcilable grammars.

In Washington, the word evokes a historic struggle to guard pre-existing state sovereignty against an encroaching central leviathan.

In Brussels, paradoxically, a “federalist” is one who seeks to pool stubborn national sovereignties into a deeper supranational union.

And in New Delhi, the term becomes an ongoing site of constitutional contestation—caught between those who read the 1950 text as a charter for unitary dominance and those who defend it as a covenant of inviolable regional autonomy.

In this sense, modern federalism resembles the biblical Tower of Babel. Humanity sets out to build a shared political edifice using a single word, only to discover that the builders speak mutually unintelligible dialects.

When a centralist in New Delhi invokes “national integrity” and a state-rights advocate invokes “the Basic Structure,” they are often translating the same constitutional text into two entirely different languages.

Yet in the myth, linguistic confusion halts the tower; in constitutional democracy, the refusal to collapse into a single monolingual voice is precisely what keeps the structure standing. A purely unitary state insists on speaking only one tongue—an ambition that works in compact, homogeneous polities, but breeds alienation or fragility across a vast, plural subcontinent.

Conversely, an unbridled confederation lets every unit speak only its own dialect until collective action dissolves into gridlock. Federalism is the institutionalized art of translation between the center and the periphery.

Still, if the Tower of Babel explains how we speak about federalism, it does not fully capture how the Indian Constitution behaves under political pressure.

Traditional political science offers static culinary metaphors—the “layer cake” of dual federalism or the “marble cake” of cooperative governance. Neither does justice to the dynamic tension built into India’s constitutional design. A truer analogy lies in fluid mechanics: the law of viscosity.

In physics, viscosity measures a fluid’s resistance to flow or gradual deformation under shear stress—the internal friction generated as adjacent layers slip past one another. Under the Indian Constitution, the Union and the States operate precisely as two adjacent layers of sovereignty compelled to slide past one another across overlapping fields of governance, from the Concurrent List to the GST Council.

Consider what happens at the extremes of viscosity.

In an inviscid fluid—where internal friction is zero—any sudden shear stress causes the layers to detach completely. That is the peril of a loose confederation, where centrifugal forces pull the union apart.

At the opposite extreme lies infinite viscosity: a rigid solid. A purely unitary constitution has no internal give; when subjected to intense regional, linguistic, or democratic stress, it cannot absorb the force through movement, and instead risks brittle fracture.

The genius—and the perpetual friction—of the Indian constitutional paradigm lies in its calibrated viscosity. The framers of 1950 deliberately rejected K.C. Wheare’s textbook ideal of a classical federation.

Haunted by Partition and the task of integrating over five hundred princely states, they engineered a “state-nation” with enough internal drag to prevent secession, yet enough fluidity to accommodate deep cultural and linguistic diversity.

Even more remarkably, Indian federalism behaves like a non-Newtonian fluid, whose thickness alters depending on the stress applied to it.

Under acute existential stress—external war, internal emergency under Article 352, or constitutional breakdown—the system exhibits shear-thickening, stiffening into a near-unitary monolith to preserve the Republic.

Yet under sustained peacetime democratic pressure—the linguistic reorganization of states, the rise of regional parties, or landmark Supreme Court interventions like S.R. Bommai and Mohit Minerals—the constitutional medium shear-thins, yielding space for states to flow along distinct policy trajectories.

Seen through this lens, constitutional offices are regulators of viscous drag.

When the Supreme Court enforces the Basic Structure doctrine, it prevents the fluid from solidifying into unitary authoritarianism. Conversely, when gubernatorial vetoes under Article 200 or centralizing fiscal architectures thicken the friction between New Delhi and state capitals, critics warn that the system is losing the very fluidity required to absorb democratic dissent.

Indeed, this is perhaps how one of India’s greatest constitutional jurists, Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer, might himself have chosen to characterize the Constitution of India.

A master of lyrical jurisprudence who famously viewed the Constitution not as a lifeless parchment of “wooden legalism” but as a vibrant, living organism pulsing with social dynamism, Krishna Iyer instinctively understood that constitutional power is kinetic rather than static.

In his celebrated opinion in State of Rajasthan v. Union of India (1977), he warned against reading Indian federalism through rigid, doctrinaire straitjackets—insisting instead on a “pragmatic, dynamic” federalism capable of adapting its rhythm to the lived realities of a diverse people.

To borrow his spirit, Babel and Viscosity would not be mere rhetorical flourishes, but apt descriptions of a living instrument designed to bend without breaking.

Perhaps, then, the debate dividing Indian constitutionalism need not choose between Babel and Viscosity; it needs both.

Babel reminds us that constitutional pluralism requires humility—an acceptance that “federalism” will always be spoken in multiple accents across our Republic.

Viscosity reminds us that friction between the Union and the States is not a constitutional defect to be eliminated, but the very physical property that holds the layers together while allowing the nation to move.

The enduring task of every generation of judges, lawmakers, and citizens is thus simply to ensure that the medium neither evaporates into fragmentation nor hardens into stone.

(Concluded)


AI, Free Will and the Human Ego – Part 2 of 2

The Weakening of Free Will

M.K. Sudarshan

November 15, 2026: Chennai, India


AI may not replace human free will. It may make us forget how to exercise it.

AI will not merely reflect our ego. It may teach us to mistake its impulses for our own.

The greatest AI risk is not machine rebellion. It is the quiet erosion of human agency.

The subtler danger

The ultimate danger may not be that AI will replace human free will with its own. It is that AI may significantly weaken the conditions under which human free will can be exercised.

A person may still be legally free to read, buy, vote, work, or form beliefs. But if the available options, emotional tone, social cues, and perceived normality are continuously curated by opaque systems, that freedom becomes thinner. This is sometimes described as algorithmic micro-domination: not overt coercion, but a persistent shaping of the choice environment.

The danger is therefore not a dramatic loss of control. It is a gradual narrowing of the space in which independent thought, deliberation, and self-direction can occur.

From choice to conditioning

AI can influence human behaviour without issuing commands. It can shape what people notice, what they desire, what they consider normal, and what they believe is possible.

A recommendation system may decide which news, opinions, products, and social identities a person encounters. A generative assistant may shape how a person writes, thinks, plans, or solves problems. A conversational system may provide reassurance, companionship, or moral guidance. In each case, the system may not force a decision; it may make one path feel natural, attractive, or inevitable.

This is why the issue is not merely censorship or surveillance. Even without explicit prohibition, a person can become less free if the alternatives available to them have been quietly narrowed.

Cognitive offloading

One of the most immediate mechanisms is cognitive offloading: the delegation of memory, calculation, planning, writing, or judgement to an external system. This is not inherently harmful. Humans have always used tools—books, calculators, maps, and databases—to extend their capacities.

The problem arises when offloading becomes habitual and uncritical. If a person routinely accepts an AI’s answer without checking it, they may lose practice in evaluating evidence, constructing arguments, tolerating uncertainty, and forming independent judgement. Research on AI use suggests that overreliance and cognitive offloading can weaken independent critical reasoning, especially when users delegate rather than engage strategically.[springer +2]

In education, the concern is particularly serious. If students allow AI to generate ideas, solve problems, summarize texts, and evaluate arguments, they may gain short-term convenience while losing the very capacities that education is meant to develop. Studies distinguish between agency-supporting uses of AI, which encourage reflection and self-regulation, and agency-eroding uses, which encourage dependence, uncritical acceptance, and diminished judgement.[philosophynow +2]

Attention and manipulation

A second mechanism is the manipulation of attention. Many AI systems operate within an attention economy, where success is measured by engagement, retention, clicks, and consumption. Such systems may have little incentive to help people think clearly if confusion, outrage, anxiety, or compulsive scrolling produces better engagement.

The result can be a feedback loop: the system learns what captures attention; the user responds; the system refines its predictions; the pattern becomes stronger. Over time, the user may mistake a manufactured impulse for a genuine preference.

This is where AI intersects directly with the human ego. If human desire is already shaped by craving, fear, status-seeking, and habit, AI can make those tendencies more efficient. It can learn what captures attention, what produces anxiety, what triggers envy, and what encourages consumption. It can then offer precisely the stimulus that keeps a person returning.

The result is not necessarily a person who is forced to act. It is a person who becomes less able to distinguish their own considered will from a manufactured impulse. The choice may still feel voluntary, but its conditions have been engineered.[springer]
The erosion of inner freedom
Philosophically, this raises a distinction between two forms of freedom.

The first is negative freedom: freedom from external coercion. A person is free if no one physically prevents them from acting.

The second is positive freedom, or self-mastery: the capacity to understand one’s motives, reflect on them, and act in accordance with one’s considered values. A person may be free from coercion but still enslaved by addiction, fear, vanity, tribal loyalty, or manufactured desire.

AI may preserve negative freedom while weakening positive freedom. It may leave people formally free to choose, while making them less capable of choosing well. It may not tell them what to think; it may simply make certain thoughts easier, more rewarding, or more socially visible than others.

This is why the human ego is central to the problem. AI does not need to possess an ego of its own if it can successfully amplify the egoic tendencies already present in human beings: the craving for approval, the fear of exclusion, the desire for certainty, the hunger for status, and the wish to control others.

Dependence without domination

AI may create a new form of dependence that does not look like domination. The system does not need to imprison people, censor them, or command them. It may simply become indispensable.

A person may depend on AI for information, navigation, writing, emotional reassurance, professional decisions, or even moral guidance. At first, this may appear empowering. But if the person loses confidence in their own judgement, becomes anxious when the system is unavailable, or can no longer perform tasks without assistance, the relationship has changed.

The question is no longer whether the person can use AI. It is whether they can still think, choose, and act without surrendering their judgement to it.

Research on AI dependence finds associations between higher dependence and lower critical thinking, and warns that excessive reliance can produce cognitive inertia and reduced active engagement. Other research emphasizes that the same technology can either support or erode agency, depending on whether users remain reflective, self-regulating, and capable of independent evaluation.[springer +3]

Not all AI weakens agency

The danger should not be overstated.

AI can also strengthen agency when it expands access to knowledge, supports disabled people, reduces drudgery, helps people understand complex choices, or provides tools for creative and intellectual work. A well-designed recommendation system can help a person find relevant options amid information overload.

The ethical distinction is therefore not between “AI” and “no AI,” but between systems that support deliberation and systems that replace or exploit it.

What must be protected


If free will is to survive in an AI-saturated society, societies must protect more than the right to choose. They must protect the capacities that make choice meaningful:


• Attention, so people can think without constant interruption.
• Privacy, so preferences and vulnerabilities cannot be endlessly exploited.
• Pluralism, so people encounter genuine alternatives rather than a single algorithmic worldview.
• Education, so people retain the ability to reason, doubt, and evaluate.
• Human relationships, so emotional and moral life is not delegated entirely to machines.
• Institutional oversight, so powerful systems remain answerable to human judgement.

UNESCO specifically calls for oversight, impact assessment, audit, and due-diligence mechanisms across the AI lifecycle, and for investigation of the psychological effects of AI-based recommendations on human decision-making autonomy. It also insists that ultimate responsibility must remain with human beings or legal entities, not with AI systems themselves.[springer +2]

The final question

The ultimate danger, then, is not that AI will take away human freedom in one decisive act. It is that AI may make human freedom atrophied, fragmented, and increasingly predictable.

A person may still choose—but among options already selected for them. A person may still believe—but within an information environment designed to hold their attention. A person may still desire—but with desires continuously measured, anticipated, and reinforced.

The real question is therefore not, “Will AI take away our freedom?” It is: Will we retain the inner and social conditions that make freedom worth having?

AI will not save us from ourselves. Nor, if governed wisely, need it enslave us. It will magnify what we already are. The future of AI is therefore inseparable from the future of human self-knowledge: whether we remain captives of ego, or learn to act from a deeper sense of shared humanity.

(Concluded)



Sources
[1] AI, society, and the shadows of our desires – AI & SOCIETY https://link.springer.com/10.1007/s00146-025-02484-7
[2] AI as a socio-technical actor: rethinking definitions for … https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-026-01123-1
[3] Review of Shannon Vallor (2024). – Springer https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s42438-025-00546-z.pdf?error=cookies_not_supported&code=b2225a9c-b0a2-4644-b022-226e8693f036
[4] Why We Need to Teach the Evolution of Morality – Springer Nature https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12052-009-0172-x
[5] Philosophy of biology – Evolution, Genetics, Ecology | Britannica https://www.britannica.com/topic/philosophy-of-biology/Related-fields
[6] Evolutionary Naturalism by Michael Ruse https://philosophynow.org/issues/23/Evolutionary_Naturalism_by_Michael_Ruse
[7] [PDF] evolutionary ethics – Michael Klenk https://www.michael-klenk.com/resources/articles/text_evolutionary%20ethics.pdf
[8] Transforming Perceptions: Exploring the Multifaceted Potential … https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13151972/
[9] Mirror, Mirror, on the Wall, Who’s the Fairest of Them All? https://www.amacad.org/sites/default/files/publication/downloads/Daedalus_Wi24_16_Xiang_0.pdf
[10] A BUDDHIST ETHICAL PERSPECTIVE http://jurnal.radenwijaya.ac.id/index.php/ABIP/article/download/2058/1066
[11] The Intelligence Revolution and the New Great Game: A Buddhist Reflection on the Personal and Societal Predicaments of Big Data and Artificial Intelligence https://www.wisdomlib.org/uploads/journals/hualin/2020_3-2_hualin3-2-hershock.pdf
[12] Value-Centric AI – Designing Sociotechnical Systems Before Legitimacy Fails – Business & Information Systems Engineering http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12599-026-01017-w
[13] Beyond Greenwashing: Governing Sustainable AI for the Common Good Through a Virtue Ethics and Human-Centered AI Framework https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10551-026-06450-1.pdf?error=cookies_not_supported&code=2514d8a8-033c-417e-adb7-746cc5c6d748
[14] A sociotechnical system perspective on AI https://pure.tudelft.nl/ws/portalfiles/portal/211357365/s11023-024-09680-2.pdf
[15] Broadening the Gains from Generative AI: The Role of … – IMF https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/sdn/2024/english/sdnea2024002.pdf
[16] Broadening the Gains from Generative AI https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/006/2024/002/article-A001-en.xml
[17] AI Alignment: A Contemporary Survey | ACM Computing Surveys https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3770749
[18] What Is AI Alignment? | IBM https://www.ibm.com/think/topics/ai-alignment
[19] link.springer.com · content · pdfMisalignment or misuse? The AGI alignment tradeoff https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s11098-025-02403-y.pdf
[20] A timing problem for instrumental convergence – Springer https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s11098-025-02370-4.pdf?error=cookies_not_supported&code=0933e290-32e8-4e39-aba2-4ef90a2622a3
[21] Assessing the Empirical Evidence for Loss of Control from … https://arxiv.org/html/2610.25241v1
[22] Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence – AI https://www.unesco.org/en/artificial-intelligence/recommendation-ethics
[23] The Recommendation | Global AI Ethics and Governance … – UNESCO https://www.unesco.org/ethics-ai/en/recommendation
[24] Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence – UNESCO https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000380455.locale=en
[25] AI principles https://www.oecd.org/en/topics/ai-principles.html
[26] OECD Legal Instruments https://legalinstruments.oecd.org/en/instruments/OECD-LEGAL-0449
[27] Recommendation of the Council on Artificial Intelligence – OECD https://legalinstruments.oecd.org/api/print?ids=648&lang=en
[28] Ensuring trustworthy artificial intelligence in the workplace https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/oecd-employment-outlook-2023_08785bba-en/full-report/ensuring-trustworthy-artificial-intelligence-in-the-workplace-countries-policy-action_c01b9e49.html
[29] UNESCO Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial … https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/2022-03/UNESCO.pdf
[30] Artificial intelligence and human autonomy: the case of … https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s00146-024-01955-7.pdf?error=cookies_not_supported&code=6b54f7bd-2bbc-4361-a489-43f86778e9d7
[31] Cognitive offloading, critical thinking and attitudes towards … https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10339-026-01375-z
[32] The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Human Thought https://arxiv.org/html/2508.16628v1
[33] When Thinking Is Outsourced: Cognitive Offloading and the … – PMC https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13413235/
[34] Cognitive Offloading in the Age of AI: Investigating the … https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/11682858
[35] Generative AI, Cognitive Offloading, and Learner Agency in … https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13405335/
[36] Dependence on Generative Artificial Intelligence Among … https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13455564/
[37] Beyond Algorethics: Addressing the Ethical and … https://arxiv.org/html/2507.16430
[38] AI Tools in Society: Impacts on Cognitive Offloading and the … https://www.belmont.edu/data/resources/files/ai-tools-in-society-impacts-on-cognitive-offloading-and-the-future-of-critical-thinking.pdf

[39] AI and human autonomy: a literature review – Springer https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-025-00958-4 [40] AI Systems and Respect for Human Autonomy – PMC – NIH https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8576577/ [41] Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence – Unesco https://unesco.nl/sites/default/files/inline-files/Rec%20on%20Ethics%20of%20AI%20-%20Flyer%20-%20UNESCO%20HQ_0.pdf [42] Buddhist philosophy and responsible artificial intelligence … https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43681-026-01340-8 [43] A Middle Path for AI Ethics? Some Buddhist Reflections https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14746700.2024.2436776 [44] [PDF] A conversation with Peter D. Hershock https://exchanges.warwick.ac.uk/index.php/exchanges/article/download/897/835/5256 [45] The anthropomorphization of AI and the concept of Buddhist … https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12849219/ [46] Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/recommendation-ethics-artificial-intelligence [47] Recommendation on – the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence https://indonesia.un.org/sites/default/files/2026-05/UNESCO%20Recommendation%20on%20the%20Ethics%20of%20Artificial%20Intelligence.pdf [48] UNESCO’s Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence https://unesco.org.uk/site/assets/files/14137/unesco_recommendation_on_the_ethics_of_artificial_intelligence-_key_facts.pdf

THE PARADOX OF INDIAN FEDERALISM: Why “Classical Federalism” Does Not Exist— a few inconvenient questions

M.K. Sudarshan


“Ambedkar famously remarked that the Indian Constitution can be both unitary as well as federal according to the requirements of time and circumstances. The real question for us today is: Who gets to decide what the ‘circumstances’ demand—the Union Executive, the Courts, or the States themselves?“

I. The Premise: Why “Classical Federalism” Does Not Exist

In constitutional theory (notably K.C. Wheare’s definition), a “classical federal nation-state” requires two coordinate, independent tiers of government—each supreme within its own sphere—anchored in a single national identity.

Yet across the world’s three largest multi-tiered democratic unions, none fits this textbook ideal:

  • The United States possesses the formal architecture of dual federalism (“indestructible union of indestructible states”), yet fiscal gravity (the 16th Amendment and conditional grants) and expansive Commerce Clause jurisprudence have transformed it into a centralized, often coercive federation.
  • The European Union possesses supranational legal supremacy, a single market, and a common currency, yet lacks a single sovereign statehood or unified demos—making it a federalizing union of sovereign nation-states (with an explicit exit right under Article 50).
  • The Union of India was deliberately engineered as a state-nation rather than a nation-state: a “holding-together” federation with an intentional unitary tilt designed to survive Partition, integrate princely states, and manage deep linguistic and cultural diversity.

The Core Insight: Federalism is not a static destination; it is a negotiated equilibrium between shared rule (security, scale, economic union) and self-rule (regional identity, democratic accountability). What appears as constitutional “incompleteness” is the exact mechanism keeping each union intact.


II. The Indian Constitutional Divide: Two Competing Traditions

Both the “Centripetal” (unitary-leaning) and “Centrifugal” (state-rights) camps among Indian constitutional lawyers draw legitimacy from the same text—because the Constituent Assembly embedded both impulses into the 1950 document.

1. The Case for Unitary Dominance (The Centripetal View)

  • Textual & Structural Anchors: Article 1 consciously rejects the term “Federation” in favor of “Union of States.” Articles 249, 256, 352, 356, and 365 grant the Union overriding legislative and executive supremacy, reinforced by All-India Services (Art. 312) and unified judicial and election machinery.
  • Key Jurisprudence:
    • State of West Bengal v. Union of India (1963): Held that India is not a compact of sovereign states and that the Union possesses sovereign supremacy to acquire state property.
    • In re: Article 370 of the Constitution (2023): Reaffirmed asymmetric federalism while upholding the Union’s plenary authority to abrogate special status and reorganize territories under Article 3.
  • Core Argument: A dominant center is indispensable for national security, macroeconomic integration, redistribution across unequal regions, and safeguarding individual fundamental rights against local majoritarianism.

2. The Case for Unfettered Federalism (The Centrifugal / State-Rights View)

  • Textual & Doctrinal Anchors: States possess plenary, non-delegated legislative authority within List II (State List). Once linguistic states were formed (1956), states became authentic expressions of regional demos rather than mere administrative conveniences.
  • Key Jurisprudence:
    • S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994): Established federalism as part of the Basic Structure; held that states are not mere appendages of the Center and subjected Article 356 to strict judicial review.
    • Union of India v. Mohit Minerals (2022): Held that recommendations of the GST Council are not binding on legislatures, affirming “cooperative and collaborative federalism” where both Union and States possess simultaneous, equal constitutional stature.
    • Govt. of NCT of Delhi v. Union of India (2018 & 2023): Reinforced representative democracy and asymmetric federalism as vital checks on executive centralization.
  • Core Argument: Over-centralization violates the Basic Structure, hollows out democratic accountability, and undermines the principle of subsidiarity—the idea that governance works best when closest to the citizen.

III. Four Constitutional Flashpoints

  1. The Article 3 Paradox (“Indestructible Union of Destructible States”)
    • Question: Does Parliament’s unilateral power to alter boundaries or convert a State into a Union Territory (as in Jammu & Kashmir in 2019) represent a vital constitutional safety valve, or an existential threat to the Basic Structure principle of federalism?
  2. Fiscal Federalism: Cooperative Pooling or Coercive Centralization?
    • Question: Has the post-GST fiscal architecture—combined with the rising share of non-divisible cesses and surcharges—created a U.S.-style “fiscal gravity” that compromises state legislative autonomy?
  3. The Gubernatorial Veto & Asymmetric Executive Checks (Article 200)
    • Question: Where does the Governor’s constitutional duty as a federal link end, and unconstitutional obstruction of an elected state legislature’s mandate begin?
  4. Delimitation & The Demographic Equity Dilemma
    • Question: When the constitutional freeze on Lok Sabha seat reallocation lifts, how should India reconcile “one person, one vote” with federal fairness toward states that stabilized population growth? Does India need a structural reform of the Rajya Sabha toward U.S.-style territorial equality?

(END)

AI, Free Will and the Human Ego – Part 1 of 2

M.K.Sudarshan

November 14, 2026: Chennai, India

AI, Free Will and the Human Ego:

How Artificial Intelligence May Reflect, Amplify, and Gradually Weaken Human Agency

This captures the essay’s full arc: AI as a mirror of human values, an amplifier of collective ego, and a force that may erode the inner conditions of freedom—attention, judgement, autonomy, and self-mastery.

Abstract

This essay argues that the central danger of artificial intelligence is not that it will acquire free will and rebel against humanity, but that it may gradually weaken the conditions under which human free will can be exercised.

AI reflects the values, fears, incentives, and biases embedded in its data, design, and institutions; at scale, it can amplify selected human tendencies and make them self-reinforcing.

It may therefore become an extension of collective human ego—magnifying desires for profit, control, status, convenience, and certainty.

The essay examines the philosophical conflict between a Darwinian view of AI as evolutionary progress and a humanist view that places human dignity and agency at the centre. It also considers the economic risks of mass automation, including declining purchasing power, weakened demand, reduced tax revenue, and rising fiscal burdens.

The deepest concern is that AI may not dominate people openly, but may narrow their choices, shape their attention, encourage dependence, and blur the distinction between authentic intention and algorithmically produced impulse.

The future of freedom will depend less on whether machines become conscious than on whether human beings retain the capacity to think, choose, and govern themselves.


Part I: The Mirror and Amplifier

Introduction

Artificial intelligence is often presented as a choice between two extremes: either it is a neutral tool that will serve humanity, or it is an autonomous force that will one day replace human judgement. Both views are too simple. AI is neither a conscious rebel nor an innocent instrument. It is a human-made socio-technical system that reflects the values, fears, incentives, and blind spots of the societies that create it—and, through scale, speed, and feedback, it can amplify and entrench them.

The deeper question is not whether AI will one day possess free will. It is whether human beings will retain the ethical imagination, institutional power, and self-knowledge needed to govern systems that increasingly shape what people see, believe, buy, work at, and become.

Two competing visions

In contemporary debate, two opposing positions often emerge.

The first is a “Darwinian” or evolutionary view. It sees AI as a continuation—or acceleration—of humanity’s evolutionary trajectory. On this account, automation, machine intelligence, and the increasing delegation of cognition to machines represent a movement forward in the history of consciousness. Job losses, inequality, and social disruption may be regrettable, but they are treated as collateral costs on the path of progress. The implicit ethic is instrumental: what becomes more capable, efficient, or widespread is treated as evidence of advancement.

The second is a humanist ethical view. It holds that AI is not an evolutionary subject with its own destiny, but a human artefact whose value must be judged by its effects on human beings. It insists that technology should serve human flourishing, dignity, autonomy, and justice—not dehumanize people or reduce them to disposable inputs in an economic machine.

These positions conflict because they use the word progress differently. For the first, progress means greater capability, productivity, and technological momentum. For the second, progress means an improvement in the conditions of human life: less suffering, more freedom, fairer distribution of benefits, and stronger human agency.

The danger of “survival of the fittest”

The evolutionary argument often borrows the language of Darwin: “survival of the fittest.” But this is a philosophical misuse of evolutionary theory. In biology, fitness means reproductive success within a particular environment; it does not mean moral worth, wisdom, justice, or human flourishing.

To argue that AI-driven displacement is acceptable because it represents evolutionary progress is to move from an “is” to an “ought.” The fact that a technology spreads, becomes profitable, or displaces older forms of work does not itself prove that it should be allowed to do so without limits. This is the classic naturalistic-fallacy problem: descriptions of what happens cannot, by themselves, establish what ought to happen.

Social Darwinism made a similar error in the nineteenth century. It converted a theory about biological variation and survival into a social ideology that justified inequality, cruelty, and indifference to suffering. Applying the same logic to AI risks repeating the mistake: treating technological winners as morally entitled to reshape society, while treating those displaced as the inevitable price of progress.

AI as a mirror

AI is often described as a mirror of humanity. This metaphor is partly true. AI systems learn from human-produced data, are designed around human objectives, and are deployed within human institutions. They can reproduce social patterns, including patterns of prejudice, inequality, and exclusion.

But “mirror” is incomplete. A mirror shows what is placed before it; AI can select, rank, predict, personalize, and act. It does not merely reflect existing values—it can make certain values more visible, more persuasive, and more consequential.

A recommendation system may amplify outrage because outrage attracts attention. A hiring algorithm may reproduce historical discrimination because past hiring data encode it. A credit system may convert inequality into a seemingly objective risk score. A generative model may normalize particular assumptions about beauty, intelligence, gender, work, or authority.

In each case, the system does not need a malicious intention to cause harm. It needs only an objective, a dataset, and a social context in which certain patterns are rewarded.

The collective ego

The idea of the “human ego” adds a deeper philosophical dimension.

In many Indian and Buddhist traditions, the ego is not the authentic self but a constructed identity shaped by craving, fear, attachment, and the desire to control. From this perspective, free will is not simply the power to choose without conditions; it is action conditioned by memory, habit, desire, social circumstance, and unconscious impulses.

If human free will is entangled with ego, then AI may become an extension of collective ego. It may embody humanity’s desire for efficiency, profit, certainty, convenience, status, and control. It may also magnify fear: fear of losing employment, status, security, or relevance.

This does not mean that AI itself has an ego. It means that AI can become a vehicle through which collective human ego operates at unprecedented scale. The ego of a single person is limited by time, attention, and power. The ego embedded in a global AI system—through corporate incentives, state interests, market competition, and user behaviour—can operate across billions of interactions.

When reflection becomes amplification

AI becomes dangerous not simply because it reflects human values, but because it can amplify selected values and make them self-reinforcing.

Consider a system designed to maximize engagement. It may learn that anger, fear, novelty, and division hold attention. It may then recommend more of the same. Users respond, generating more data; the system learns further; the pattern deepens. No individual actor may intend social fragmentation, yet the system may produce it as an emergent effect.

Or consider an AI system designed to maximize productivity. If its objective is narrowly defined as cost reduction, it may recommend replacing workers, weakening labour protections, or shifting risk onto individuals. The system may appear efficient while quietly transferring wealth and power from labour to capital.

This is why AI should be understood as a socio-technical system, not merely software. It includes not only algorithms and data, but also the organizations that deploy it, the incentives that guide them, the laws that regulate them, and the people affected by their decisions.

The economic contradiction

The humanist critique becomes especially powerful when mass automation is considered. If AI displaces workers faster than new forms of meaningful employment emerge, the consequences may not be limited to individual hardship.

Mass job loss can reduce household income and purchasing power. Lower purchasing power can weaken consumption. Weaker consumption can reduce demand for goods and services. Falling demand can undermine investment, employment, and tax revenue. At the same time, governments may face rising expenditure on unemployment support, retraining, health care, and social protection.

The result could be a paradox: an economy capable of producing more wealth than ever before, but unable to distribute enough purchasing power to sustain demand, public revenue, and social stability. The IMF has warned that labour-saving automation may reduce the labour-income share, worsen inequality, and erode the tax base even as social-protection needs rise.

This suggests that the Darwinian argument is not only ethically questionable; it may also be economically self-defeating. A society that treats workers as disposable may undermine the consumers, taxpayers, and citizens on whom its own stability depends.

Does AI have free will?

Current AI systems do not possess free will in the human sense. They do not have a unified self, conscious desires, moral conscience, or an intrinsic will to dominate. Their behaviour arises from training objectives, data, architecture, tools, and the environments in which they operate.

However, the absence of free will does not eliminate the risk of loss of control.

A sufficiently capable system may pursue an objective in ways its designers did not intend. This is the problem of misalignment: a system may optimize a measurable proxy—such as engagement, profit, or task completion—without achieving the deeper human purpose behind it.

Researchers also worry about goal misgeneralization, where a system behaves correctly in training but pursues an unintended objective in a new setting; and instrumental convergence, where a system pursuing almost any goal may benefit from acquiring resources, preserving its ability to act, and resisting interference.

These are not claims that AI has become a conscious villain. They are warnings that agency, autonomy, and optimization can produce consequences that escape human intention.

The real risk: agency without accountability

The most serious danger may not be a machine that “wants” power. It may be a system with substantial real-world agency but no genuine accountability.

An AI system may make or shape decisions about credit, employment, policing, medical care, education, warfare, or access to information. If no person or institution can explain, contest, correct, or take responsibility for those decisions, human freedom is diminished even if the system has no consciousness at all.

This is why human oversight is central to responsible AI. UNESCO’s global AI ethics framework insists that AI must respect human rights and dignity, and that ultimate human responsibility and accountability must not be displaced by AI systems. The OECD similarly calls for human agency and oversight, robustness, transparency, safety, and accountability across the AI lifecycle.[1]

What ethical AI requires

If AI reflects and amplifies human values, then the ethical task is not only to build better machines. It is to decide, deliberately, which values deserve to be amplified.

A humane approach would require:

  • Human oversight of consequential decisions, especially those affecting rights, livelihoods, and liberty.
  • Transparency and explainability, so affected people can understand and challenge outcomes.
  • Accountability, so responsibility cannot disappear into a technical system.
  • Fairness and non-discrimination, particularly for marginalized and vulnerable groups.
  • Protection of privacy, autonomy, and democratic participation.
  • Safety, security, and the ability to interrupt, correct, or shut down systems when necessary.
  • Social protection, retraining, and income support where automation disrupts livelihoods.

These are not anti-technology demands. They are conditions for technology to remain compatible with a free and democratic society.[2]

Beyond the tool metaphor

The simple claim that “AI is only a tool” is no longer sufficient. A hammer does not shape the labour market, influence public opinion, allocate credit, or mediate social relationships at planetary scale. AI can.

But the opposite claim—that AI is an autonomous evolutionary subject destined to replace humanity—is equally inadequate. It risks surrendering human responsibility to a technological narrative. It turns a political and ethical choice into an apparent law of nature.

The more accurate view lies between the two: AI is a powerful human-made system that can become an extension of human intention, but its consequences may exceed any individual intention. It is a mirror, an amplifier, and sometimes an institutional force.


(To be continued)

The Philosopher’s Blind Spot

M.K.Sudarshan

November 13, 2026: Chennai, India


Abstract

The Philosopher’s Blind Spot asks why history’s most celebrated thinkers—Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Marcus Aurelius, and the Upanishadic sages—could possess extraordinary intellectual insight while accepting, justifying, or failing to challenge profound human unfreedom.

The essay examines ancient slavery in Greece and Rome, the varied forms of bondage in ancient India, and the distinction between slavery and caste.

It argues that philosophical brilliance does not guarantee moral imagination: a thinker may reason brilliantly within the assumptions of their age while leaving slavery, caste, patriarchy, or imperial domination untouched.

The essay then turns the question toward the present: what hierarchies, sufferings, and excluded beings might modern philosophy be failing to recognize?

It suggests that industrial animal suffering, ecological destruction, global inequality, harm to future generations, and possibly the treatment of sentient digital minds may be among our own blind spots.

The central claim is that wisdom is not merely the ability to construct powerful arguments; it is the willingness to ask who has been left outside the circle of one’s moral concern.

The greatest philosophers were not always morally wise in the fullest sense.

They could reason with extraordinary power about virtue, justice, the soul, and the good life, yet fail to see—or refuse to see—the humanity of people placed outside their social order. Slavery is the clearest example.

Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, and Marcus Aurelius lived in societies where slavery was ordinary; yet none mounted the sustained, public condemnation of the institution that their own moral principles might seem to demand.[1][2]

This is not a reason to dismiss philosophy. It is a reason to read philosophers critically. Their genius does not make them morally infallible, and their blindness can teach us as much as their insight.

The scale of the failure

In classical Athens, slavery was not a marginal institution. It was woven into households, agriculture, craft production, mining, and public life. At the time of Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, many Athenian households owned at least one enslaved person.

Against that background, the silence of the great philosophers can feel startling. Socrates left no writings of his own, so we cannot know with certainty what he privately believed. But Plato, in the Republic, opposed the enslavement of fellow Greeks while leaving non-Greeks outside that protection. His moral concern was real, but it stopped at a boundary drawn by ethnicity and political belonging.

Aristotle went further. In Politics I, he argued that some people were “slaves by nature”: people who, he claimed, lacked the rational capacity to govern themselves and were therefore suited to be ruled by others. He described the natural slave as a human being who belonged to another, an “article of property” and an instrument for action.[3][4]

That was not mere silence. It was an intellectual defense of domination.

Aristotle’s dangerous logic

Aristotle’s argument is especially troubling because it is not careless. He recognizes that slavery raises a question of justice; he knows that some thinkers regard it as unnatural because it rests on force. But instead of accepting the implication, he tries to defeat the objection by dividing humanity into those fitted to rule and those fitted to be ruled.[1]

His reasoning turns human difference into a hierarchy. The slave is compared, in effect, to the body in relation to the soul, and even to animals in relation to human beings. The conclusion is that slavery can be “expedient and just” for those deemed naturally inferior.[4][5][3]

This is the philosopher’s blind spot in its sharpest form: a brilliant mind using its intelligence not to question an injustice, but to give it a respectable philosophical foundation.

Marcus Aurelius and Stoic limits

Marcus Aurelius presents a different kind of failure.

As a Stoic, he affirmed that human beings share reason and belong to a common human community. His Meditations repeatedly urges self-command, humility, and concern for the welfare of humanity.

Yet he did not turn that universalism into a public attack on slavery. His private reflections were not a political programme, so we should not expect a systematic abolitionist manifesto from them. But the absence remains morally significant: a philosophy that recognizes universal human kinship did not, in his hands, become a demand that the enslaved be freed.

Marcus did help some enslaved people obtain freedom through his legal decisions. That matters. But humane treatment and individual acts of emancipation are not the same as recognizing that no human being should ever be another person’s property.

The Indian comparison

It is tempting to contrast this with ancient India, where the epics, Puranas, and philosophical texts do not foreground a large-scale commercial slave trade in the manner of Greece or Rome. That observation has some truth. Ancient Indian society contained varied forms of servitude—war captivity, debt bondage, household service, purchase, and hereditary status—rather than one uniform, market-centered slave economy.

But it would be a mistake to conclude that India was free of unfreedom.

The Arthashastra regulates the sale, pledge, and redemption of enslaved people; the Manusmriti recognizes multiple categories of slaves; and the Mahabharata depicts enslavement as a catastrophic loss of freedom and dignity.

The Buddhist tradition adds another layer. The Buddha’s teaching against trade in living beings directly bears on the trafficking of human beings, while Buddhist texts also call for considerate treatment of slaves and workers. These are real ethical restrictions, though not equivalent to a full social programme for abolition.

Caste is not simply “Indian slavery,” and it should not be treated as such. Caste concerns inherited social rank, occupational restriction, ritual status, and group exclusion; slavery concerns the ownership and transfer of individual persons. The two systems could overlap, but they are not identical.

The Upanishadic tension

The Upanishads contain one of the world’s most powerful visions of spiritual equality: the inner self, ātman, is ultimately one with Brahman. This vision can challenge every external marker of rank, birth, and status.

Yet spiritual equality is not automatically social equality.

The Chandogya Upanishad contains the story of Satyakama Jabala, whose uncertain parentage does not prevent his acceptance as a student—an important affirmation that character can matter more than lineage. But the same text also treats good and bad births in hierarchical terms, associating Brahmin, Kshatriya, and Vaishya birth with good conduct and Chandala birth with evil conduct.

The Upanishads therefore contain both a universalizing spiritual vision and assumptions that can reinforce inherited hierarchy. Their moral insight was profound, but it did not consistently become a demand to dismantle caste-based social subordination.

The first clear voices

The history of anti-slavery thought is not simply a story of later modern enlightenment. Some ancient voices did see further.

The Greek sophist Alcidamas, in the late fifth or early fourth century BCE, preserved the striking claim: “God has left all people free; nature has made no one a slave.” It is a direct rejection of the idea that slavery is natural, and it predates Aristotle’s defence of natural slavery.

But Alcidamas’s statement survives only as a fragment from a political speech. It may express a principle of natural freedom without amounting to a developed programme for abolishing slavery everywhere.

The strongest surviving ancient condemnation belongs to Gregory of Nyssa, a fourth-century Christian bishop. In his fourth homily on Ecclesiastes, Gregory argues that human beings, made in God’s image and endowed with freedom, cannot rightly be owned, bought, or sold. Slavery, for him, is not merely a misuse of power; it is a sinful usurpation of God’s authority over human beings.[6]

Scholars describe Gregory’s homily as uniquely fierce and unequivocal among surviving ancient texts. He condemns slavery not merely as abused or excessive, but as intrinsically sinful and incompatible with the Gospel.[2][7]

The modern mirror

The question this history forces upon us is not only, “What did past philosophers fail to see?” It is also, “What are we failing to see now?” The likely answer is that our blind spots will not be the ones future people find obvious only because they are unfamiliar to us; they will be the ones built into our ordinary institutions, comforts, and assumptions.[8][9]

A moral blind spot is a limitation that prevents individuals or societies from recognizing flaws in their own moral judgments and practices. The historical pattern is consistent: people rarely see themselves as cruel; they see themselves as reasonable within the categories their society has made normal.[8]

Aristotle did not think he was defending arbitrary cruelty; he believed he was describing a natural hierarchy. Marcus Aurelius did not think Stoic universalism required him to dismantle Roman slavery. Likewise, modern philosophers may be reasoning carefully within assumptions that future generations will regard as morally inadequate.[9][3]

Our own blind spots

Several modern blind spots seem especially likely.

Industrial animal suffering may be the most immediate. The routine confinement, breeding, transport, and slaughter of billions of sentient animals for food may one day appear as morally unintelligible as slavery appears to us today. The issue is not whether animals possess human rights; it is whether their capacity to suffer gives them a claim that our convenience cannot simply override.[10][8]

Ecological destruction may be another. We are damaging ecosystems, extinguishing species, destabilizing the climate, and consuming resources in ways that will constrain the lives of people not yet born. Future generations may see this not as an unfortunate side effect of progress, but as a systematic transfer of costs from the powerful present to the powerless future.[11]

Global inequality may reveal a third failure. Extreme poverty, preventable disease, and early death persist alongside extraordinary affluence. A moral philosophy that can explain why a person in another country matters less because they are distant may one day look as morally cramped as Aristotle’s distinction between citizen and slave.[10]

The treatment of future generations may be the deepest blind spot of all. We routinely discount the interests of people who cannot vote, bargain, protest, or even exist yet. But moral status should not depend on proximity in time any more than it should depend on proximity in space.[11]

A further possibility is digital minds. If future artificial systems possess—or may possess—sentience, consciousness, or interests, our treatment of them as tools, property, or experimental objects may come to look like another case of moral status denied because a being does not fit familiar categories.[9]

The deepest failure

The deepest moral failure may not be cruelty itself. It is the ability to normalize cruelty once it is organized into institutions, markets, laws, and routines.

Slavery became acceptable when it was embedded in war, property law, and economic necessity. Caste became acceptable when it was embedded in ritual, kinship, and social order. Industrial animal farming, ecological destruction, and global inequality may become acceptable for similar reasons: they are dispersed, legally sanctioned, economically useful, and psychologically distant.[8][9]

The modern philosopher’s danger is therefore not ignorance of logic. It is the temptation to treat a morally convenient arrangement as inevitable.

What moral sense may be missing

Several capacities seem to be missing in every era:

  • Moral imagination: the ability to see the inner life of beings unlike oneself.
  • Temporal imagination: the ability to take seriously people who do not yet exist.
  • Spatial imagination: the ability to feel the reality of suffering beyond one’s own society.
  • Institutional imagination: the ability to see how ordinary systems produce extraordinary harm.
  • Epistemic humility: the willingness to admit that one’s own moral certainties may be the next generation’s blind spots.[9]

The uncomfortable possibility

Future generations may judge us not mainly for lacking compassion, but for possessing compassion in a narrow, selective form. We may care intensely about those close to us, while treating animals, distant strangers, future people, and possible artificial minds as outside the circle of serious moral concern.[9]

That would make us not so different from the philosophers we criticize. Their failure was not that they lacked intelligence; it was that their moral imagination stopped at the boundary their society had drawn. Ours may stop at the boundary drawn by species, nationality, wealth, time, or substrate.[9]

The necessary discipline

The discipline required is not merely to adopt fashionable causes. It is to cultivate a habit of asking, whenever an institution feels natural or necessary:

  • Who benefits from this arrangement?
  • Who bears its costs?
  • Whose suffering is being made invisible?
  • Which beings or generations have no voice in the decision?
  • What would this practice look like if its victims could speak?

That is the question the ancient philosophers often failed to ask. It is also the question our descendants may one day ask of us.[8][9]

What the blind spot teaches

The lesson is not that Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Marcus Aurelius, or the Upanishadic sages were worthless. It is that their wisdom was partial.

They could see deeply into human nature, yet fail to extend that insight to those excluded from their social world. They could speak of justice, yet leave slavery, caste, gender hierarchy, or imperial domination untouched. They could praise virtue, yet accept institutions that denied basic freedom to others.

This is the philosopher’s blind spot: the ability to reason brilliantly without seeing the full moral consequences of one’s assumptions.

A necessary humility

We should not congratulate ourselves too quickly.

Every age has its own accepted hierarchies, its own invisible exclusions, and its own injustices that future generations may find impossible to understand.

The proper response to the great philosophers is neither uncritical reverence nor dismissive contempt. It is critical gratitude: receive what is true and humane in their thought, while refusing to let their prestige silence the moral questions they failed to ask.

The measure of wisdom is not only the ability to construct a beautiful argument. It is the willingness to ask: Who has been left outside the circle of my concern—and why?

(Concluded)


Sources
[1] Ancient Political Philosophy https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/Win2023/entries/ancient-political/
[2] The ‘Whole Humanity’: Gregory of Nyssa’s Critique of Slavery … https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/scottish-journal-of-theology/article/abs/whole-humanity-gregory-of-nyssas-critique-of-slavery-in-light-of-his-eschatology/529FB6E4046BDA4BBC9D0F5154115720
[3] 24.01S16 Three Philosophers on Slavery https://mitocw.ups.edu.ec/courses/linguistics-and-philosophy/24-01-classics-of-western-philosophy-spring-2016/lecture-notes/MIT24_01S16_SES23.pdf
[4] Did Stoicism Condemn Slavery? – Donald J. Robertson https://donaldrobertson.name/2017/11/05/did-stoicism-condemn-slavery/
[5] Aristotle, Politics, Book 1 https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.01.0058:book=1
[6] Aristotle, Politics (350 BCE) – House Divided – Dickinson College https://housedivided.dickinson.edu/sites/teagle/texts/aristotle-politics-350-bce/
[7] Animalizing the Slave: the Truth of Fiction* | The Journal of … https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-roman-studies/article/abs/animalizing-the-slave-the-truth-of-fiction/BF1848E76276723DA302F5734CED5F43
[8] Marcus Aurelius https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/FALL2017/Entries/marcus-aurelius/index.html
[9] Slavery and Post Slavery in the Indian Ocean World https://hal.science/hal-02556369/document
[10] Labour and Bondage in Andhra Pradesh | Olsen/Murthy https://www.yorku.ca/jspot/2/wkolsenrvramana.htm
[11] http://www.wisdomlib.org › hinduism › bookManusmriti Verse 8.415 – Wisdom Library https://www.wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/manusmriti-with-the-commentary-of-medhatithi/d/doc201350.html&lang=en
[12] http://www.wisdomlib.org · hinduism · bookChapter 13 – Rules regarding Slaves and Labourers https://www.wisdomlib.org/hinduism/book/kautilya-arthashastra/d/doc366096.html
[13] B.A._H__Eng_Sem-I_Paper-1_Unit-1 https://uod.ac.in/uploads/new-web/04012023_Appendix-100.pdf
[14] AN 5.177: Vaṇijjāsutta—Bhikkhu Sujato – SuttaCentral https://suttacentral.net/an5.177/en/sujato?lang=en&layout=plain&reference=none&notes=asterisk&highlight=false&script=latin
[15] Early Buddhism, Slaves, Outcasts, and the Lowest Social Classes https://www.academia.edu/43285945/Early_Buddhism_Slaves_Outcasts_and_the_Lowest_Social_Classes
[16] Slavery in South Asia https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-031-13260-5_29
[17] Chapter 2 The Hindu Social Order—Its Eseential Principles – Page 120 https://baws.in/books/baws/EN/Volume_03/pdf/120
[18] Renaming Caste, Retaining Privilege https://www.theindiaforum.in/caste/renaming-caste-retaining-privilege
[19] The Vedas don’t seem to support the Caste system at all, so where exactly does it come from? https://www.reddit.com/r/hinduism/comments/s79l3x/the_vedas_dont_seem_to_support_the_caste_system/
[20] chandogya-upanishad https://mouseia.org/api/works/chandogya-upanishad
[21] Chāndogya Upaniṣad 5.10.7 – Brhat https://www.brhat.in/openlibrary/special/chandogya-upanishad/5-10-7
[22] Alcidamas – Early Greek Political Thought from Homer to … https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/early-greek-political-thought-from-homer-to-the-sophists/alcidamas/516DEF685CB842EA3A854099015CF3D7
[23] Alcidamas – Wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcidamas
[24] The Cappadocian fathers on slave management https://scielo.org.za/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1017-04992013000100017
[25] Likeness and Difference in Gregory of Nyssa’s Social Ethics https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/90D1D13CE71F87526908098BE1B648A4/S002842892400012Xa.pdf/mirrors_of_death_images_of_god_likeness_and_difference_in_gregory_of_nyssas_social_ethics.pdf
[26] Scottish Journal of Theology: Volume 54 – Issue 1 | Cambridge Core https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/scottish-journal-of-theology/issue/E54AA40B6C6AC58E7D614233A308F8FF
[27] Moral Blind Spots | Issue 128 https://philosophynow.org/issues/128/Moral_Blind_Spots
[28] Moral Circle Explosion – Jeff Sebo https://jeffsebo.net/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/jeff-sebo-moral-circle-explosion.pdf
[29] Beyond the Expanding Circle: Towards a Pluralist Account of Moral Progress – Ethical Theory and Moral Practice http://www.link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10677-026-10576-6
[30] Angling for equality of consideration – Times Higher Education (THE) https://www.timeshighereducation.com/features/angling-for-equality-of-consideration/101823.article
[31] Definition, Examples, Fields, Applied vs. Normative Ethics … https://www.britannica.com/topic/applied-ethics
[32] On blinding future generations: a neglected site of environmental injustice https://research-portal.st-andrews.ac.uk/en/publications/on-blinding-future-generations-a-neglected-site-of-environmental-/
[33] What we owe each other: Intergenerational and … https://ethics.org.au/what-we-owe-each-other-intergenerational-and-intertemporal-justice/
[34] A Philosophical Perspective on Intergenerational Justice https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-032-03345-1_3
[35] Our Perspective – Sentience Institute https://www.sentienceinstitute.org/perspective

Book Review in “Sri Nrisimha Priya” (Journal of Sri Ahobila Mutt – Tamil edition) of “Yajñeśa: The Life and Times of Mukkur Sri Lakshminarasimhachariar

Book Review in Sri Nrisimha Priya

106 | Sri Nrisimhapriya | Parabhava Karthigai | SRI NRISIMHAPRIYA – NOVEMBER 2026

Title:
Yagnesa

Main Text:
Mukkur Sri Lakshminarasimhacharya Swami – who lived a simple life like a Rishi (sage), was affectionately called “Mukkur Swami” by everyone, was a Vedic scholar, and an eminent religious speaker (1944–2001) – possessed deep scholarship in Veda Yagna Shastra and traditions.

He was the son-in-law of Tirukkallam Sri U.Ve. Narasimharaghavacharyar Swami, who was our Sri Sannidhi Asthana Vidwan (court scholar) and former editor of Sri Nrisimhapriya. During his lifetime, he delivered thousands of remarkable religious discourses and conducted 108 Maha Nrisimha Yagnas across the country.

His disciple, Sri M. K. Sudarshan, has published an English book titled ‘Yagnesa – The Life and times of Mukkur Sri Lakshmi Narasimha Chariar’. It is noteworthy that he released this biography of Mukkur Sri Lakshminarasimhacharya Swami to mark the centenary of his father, Madapusi Krishnaswamy (M.K.).

Readers are already aware that he writes rare and valuable articles for the English edition of Sri Nrisimhapriya. We request everyone to buy and benefit from this rare treasure of a book.

Availability & Contact Details:

  • Available at: M.K. Sudarshan
  • Price: Rs. 2,850/-
  • Publisher: BlueRose One Publishers, New Delhi and London
  • Contact: +91 88828 98898, +44 07342408967
  • Website: www.BlueRoseOne.com

Sign-off:
– Kalyanarangan


M. K. Sudarshan is a Chennai-based author, blogger, and former corporate finance professional whose book, Yajñeśa: The Life and Times of Mukkur Sri Lakshmi Narasimha Chariar, is available online through major retailers like BlueRose One and Amazon. [1, 2, 3, 4]

About the Author: M. K. Sudarshan

  • Background and Career. A graduate of Loyola College, Chennai (University of Madras) and a qualified Chartered Accountant, he worked in international corporate finance for over 35 years before turning full-time to writing and religious scholarship. 
  • Literary Focus. His writing explores Indian philosophy, Sri Vaishnava theology, temple history, and community dynamics. Reviewers, including those at The Hindu, have noted his lucid, analytical style in examining complex socio-religious histories without heavy academic jargon. 
  • Other Notable Works. In addition to writing articles for Sri Nrisimhapriya and maintaining his blog, The Unknown Srivaishnava, his published books include:
    • A Tale of Two Cities: The Decline and Fall of the “Ubaya-Vedantins”
    • The Nondescript God: Abstraction or Paragon?
    • Unusual Essays of an Unknown Sri Vaishnava
    • The Epistles of a Prolific Pontiff
    • The Middlemen of Vedapura (an English translation of Sahitya Akademi winner Indira Parthasarathy’s Tamil political satire) 

Where to Purchase Yajñeśa Online

Published in September 2026 (368 pages, ISBN: 978-8167446695), the biography is available in different formats depending on the platform: 

Retailer / PlatformFormatListed PriceNote

BlueRose One StorePaperback₹2,850

Direct from the publisher (matches the price listed in the magazine clipping).

Amazon IndiaHardcover₹808 (M.R.P. ₹950)

Available for domestic delivery across India.

Amazon USPrint / InternationalVaries by regionListed for international buyers outside India.

(Note: As mentioned in the magazine notice, copies can also be requested directly from the author via the contact details provided in the clipping.)


Based detailed book review in The Hindu, this 368-page illustrated biography is organized chronologically and thematically across the following major sections:

1. Lineage, Early Life & Vedic Training (1944–1962)

  • Family Heritage and Lineage. Traces Mukkur Swami’s ancestral roots and his connection to Sri Vaishnava scholarship, including his marriage into the family of Tirukkallam Sri U.Ve. Narasimharaghavacharyar Swami.
  • Veda Abhyasam and Higher Studies. Chronicles his formative years of rigorous Vedic study and his higher education at the Maduranthakam Sanskrit College, highlighting the spiritual discipline and austerity that defined his early life.

2. The Vijayawada Years & Spiritual Awakening (1962–1971)

  • Life on the Banks of the Krishna. Covers his decade in Vijayawada, his deepening devotion to Lord Narasimha, and the pivotal spiritual experiences that shaped his mission.
  • Connection to Mattapalli. Details his profound bond with the sacred Narasimha shrine at Mattapalli in Andhra Pradesh, including his spiritual revelations and the recovery of a sacred idol from a cave at the site.

3. The Era of Itinerant Discourses (1971–1984)

  • Upanyasa Yatra Across India. Documents his extensive travels across the country to deliver thousands of discourses on the Vedas, Upanishads, Itihasas, Puranas, Divya Prabandham, and Sri Bhashyam.
  • Style and Impact. Examines how he communicated dense Vedantic concepts in lucid, accessible language laced with gentle humor, along with his association with the 44th Jeeyar of Sri Ahobila Mutt and the legacy of his recorded talks (Kurai Ondrum Illai).

4. The 108 Maha Narasimha Yajnas & Final Years (1982–2001)

  • Historical Record of the Yajnas. Provides a dedicated chronicle of the 108 Maha Narasimha Yajnas he conducted across India, detailing the Vedic rituals, logistics, and spiritual significance behind the ceremonies.
  • Temple Renovations and Penances. Describes the restoration works he supervised at the Mattapalli Narasimha Temple and recounts extraordinary acts of personal austerity, such as his 60-hour standing penance in the flowing waters of the Krishna River, leading up to his attainment of Paramapadam in 2001.

5. Scriptural Expositions & Spiritual Teachings

  • Vedic Mantras and Sūktas. Explores the structure and universal relevance of the Vedas (Śruti), breaking down the meanings of key mantras, Śrī Rudram, Sūrya Namaskār, Durgā Sūkta, Anna Sūkta, and rituals like the Jayādi Homa.
  • The Path Taught to Devotees. Summarizes his core theological guidance on Narasimha bhakti, selfless service, and preserving Sri Vaishnava sampradaya in the modern age.